Give an example of a nonempty subset UU of R2\mathbf R^2 such that UU is closed under scalar multiplication, but UU is not a subspace of R2\mathbf R^2.


We must construct a UU that isn't closed under addition (see 1c/7). Let UU be the union of two lines through the origin

U={(x,0):xR}{(0,y):yR}U = \{(x,0) : x \in \mathbf{R}\} \cup \{(0,y) : y \in \mathbf{R}\}

Clearly UU \ne \emptyset and λuU\lambda u \in U but any nonzero (x,0)+(0,y)=(x,y)U(x,0) + (0,y) = (x,y) \notin U hence UU is not a subspace.